Tuesday 18 December 2012

Minimum Alcohol Pricing Will Be Good For Pubs?

Well, this has been the claim by CAMRA anyway. But, you know, I don't reckon they have fully thought through the inevitable consequences of such a concept being widely accepted.

The Sheffield University study which the whole charade is based upon - madcap fantasy such as it is - already has a clause designed to impose the same on the on-trade in due course. In fact, it is claimed that extending minimum pricing to pubs too is the best possible outcome.
Differential minimum pricing for on-trade and off-trade leads to more substantial reductions in consumption (30p off-trade together with an 80p on-trade minimum price -2.1% versus -0.6% for 30p only; 40p together with 100p -5.4% compared to -2.6% for 40p only). This is firstly because much of the consumption by younger and hazardous drinking groups (including those at increased risk of criminal offending due to high intake on a particular day) occurs in the on-trade. It is also because increasing prices of cheaper alcohol in the on-trade dampens down the behaviour switching effects when off-trade prices are increased.
So, while Cameron is harassed by his cabinet insisting he just take his medication and shut his bloody cakehole, it's not too surprising to see the first victims of minimum alcohol pricing being ... pubs!
Two Newcastle bars are set to become the first in the UK to be licensed to sell alcohol at a minimum price in excess of a pound a unit. 
Decantus (30-32 Grey St) and the Grey St Café Bar and Grill (77 Grey St/21-27 Market St) have been awarded a premises licence subject to a condition that alcohol is sold at set prices which equate to minimum price of £1.25 per unit of alcohol. 
This is nearly three times the 45p per unit price currently subject to government consultation.
A modest starter for ten but, now it is installed as a condition, only a fool would believe it won't rise whenever some councillor wants yo generate a self-righteous headline in the local rag. And, once Newcastle politicians trumpet how brilliant their genius idea is (well, they're hardly going to admit it has failed, are they?), the scope for applying it to other pubs will be irresistible.

Wham! Before you know it, that's yer Wetherspoons under the council's price control mechanism.

No wonder Wetherspoons owner, Tim Martin, is so forthright about the danger minimum alcohol pricing will present to the on-trade.
"It's utter bollocks, basically."

Hey, CAMRA, you're not helping much, you know.


DaveAtherton20 said...

I sent the link to Pub's Minister Andrew Griffiths MP which he retweeted.

David Atherton ‏@DaveAtherton20

@agriffithsmp 2 Newcastle bars only granted alcohol license if they agree to sell at a minimum price of £1.25 a unit.http://www.newcastle.gov.uk/news-story/newcastle-leads-way-minimum-pricing# …

Retweeted by Andrew Griffiths MP

Chris said...

CAMRA - evidence that restricting alcohol intake to real ale addles the brain

c777 said...

At this rate you will be brewing your own, in secret.
With the rest of us.

Dick_Puddlecote said...

The schadenfreude is building, isn't it?

Mark.S said...

Do CAMRA have something against pubs?
First the supporting the smoking ban and now this.

Alan Bates said...

At 4.2%, 1 pint contains around 2.4 units and at £1.25 per unit this is, as near as damn it, £3 per pint - as a minimum.

No need to brew in secret as long as you don't sell it*. Looking pretty attractive. But, of course, over 65 I am only allowed 1.5 units so I don't need to worry!
I don't know the legal position of sharing the cost of ingredients amongst fellow jewel thieves.